1. As a guest you have limited access to the forums.
  2. Membership is free.
  3. So why not Sign up now!

Not a Troll post about American politics, from an European

Discussion in 'Politics & Current Affairs' started by kingshadow2, Oct 19, 2020.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. pussycat

    pussycat Administrator Staff Member

    One of the main problems when talking about "America" is that there isn't one. There are really several separate countries in the "USA", they just won't admit it. (you could say the same about Canada, but your thread is about the US, so I'll stick to it).
    You have the Northeast - New England, New York, maybe Pennsylvania - which are mostly liberal in their thinking, vote mostly Democrat, and tend not to care too much about religion, with exceptions of course.
    You have the South, sometimes referred to as Jesusland, which mostly votes Republican (but can vacillate), tend to be quite religious at least outwardly, and includes Florida, which hasn't a clue what it is.
    The Northeast and the South seem to truly detest eachother, for reasons probably beyond the scope of this discussion.
    You have the West coast, California etc., which has very liberal thinking (not unlike Canada in many ways), doesn't hate anybody and almost always votes Democrat.
    In between, you have the Midwest. This is the true American Bible Belt. They are almost all Republican.

    If you get the impression that religion seems to play a larger role here than you may be used to, well, it does. It really is beyond comprehension to most of us north of the border - Canada being a very secular country - but, it's their country, so be it. We don't care, as long as they don't try to impose their viewpoint on the rest of us.

    The sad part is that what was for a period of time, a feeling of friendship that existed between the two nations, is now gone.
    A majority - a large majority - of Canadians do not trust the United States. Notice I did not say Trump. This shift started before that, he just accelerated it. And worse still, a small, but significant, portion of the population consider the USA as an enemy. That would have been unheard of 10 years ago.

    I honestly hope the US can sort out it's problems, but I don't see how. They may well be on the verge of a civil war, I just hope it doesn't spill over to here.
    You see, Kingdark, we don't live in Scandinavia. We're NEXT DOOR.

    Have a good day.
     
    orly6666, Brutus58 and Dane like this.
  2. kingshadow2

    kingshadow2 Account Deleted

    Thank you, that was also very insightful :) . And no country has the same impact on the entire world. Be it trade or alliance politics. The Nato countries have all tript carefully around Trump in fear of losing the alliances most powerful and important member. With US military bases and prescens all over Europa, the politics in US is kinda important here also.

    I stated in the start I'm in most cases Liberal, and that effects how I view Trump and the right wing politics in US. But I have truly come to know and like people with that political standpoint. And when you get to know people, there are often some well founded reasons for there beliefs and standpoint. I hate to se how devided the US are this days, and mabe always have been from time to time. They are to big to have politics that can feel relevant to many grupes and it always changes what grupes feel left out.

    I really can understand how Trump for many can seem like a good choice when younare tired of politicians. And I do guess he even might have done some of the things he have promised. I still can't understand how people support him, but I am trying to, and this was the platform I hoped could do that.

    In my country neo Nazis and other anti immigrant groups have more supporters then ever. When they have protests and meetings, there are always anti demonstrations and they are pyshicaly attacked. I hate to see that. It gives them publizety and sympathy. But most importantly, no one really listens. Because they should. They should stay silently and listen. And then make there case calmly and rassionaly.

    To ignore and ridicule people of difrent views is always the wrong aproche. That never makes anyone change there view. Friendship and good calm friendly discussions on the other hand might.

    A good day to you also :)
     
    Dane likes this.
  3. Neophyte

    Neophyte Administrator Staff Member

    There are two major reasons why Trump is so popular in the United States. 1st is that he is not a politician. We have been ruled over by politicians for generations and the people are sick and tired of the constant lies and deceit of the political class. Trump came along and gave the people a viable alternative to the entrench politicians. 2nd is that he does what he promised to do, or tries to do what he promised. Trump is transparent enough in his actions for the people to see that even in the cases where he hasn't fulfilled his promises, you can see that its others that are blocking his attempts. I see Democrats as promising anything and everything in order to get elected and after they are elected, they do as they damn well please with total disregards to what the people want. And the sad state of Democrat voters are that they are so thoroughly conditioned and brainwashed, that they keep voting for the same people, no matter how badly they are screwed over. You can tell that the Democrat voters are brainwashed because, metaphorically, if you try to tell them the truth, they will stick their fingers in their ears and say la la la la la. The last non-politician that made a significant run for president was Ross Perot, but the people weren't as disgusted by the establishment politicians at the time he ran. By the way he ran as his own political party, not as a Democrat or Republican.

    A lot of people think that Trump is the cause of everything that is going wrong is their life, but many well renowned people say that Trump is the result of failure of the establishment politicians.
     
    Last edited: Oct 22, 2020
    LuckyDuck, EggHead, orly6666 and 2 others like this.
  4. Dane

    Dane Account Deleted

    Sorry guys! I totally missed exactly what you were asking.
    Pussycat and I both know how push each others buttons, all in fun though. I don't consider them arguments, but more of opinion banter.

    Back on topic.....
    The number one reason that Trump is so well like by conservatives is his stance and actions about abortions.
    We conservatives have always believed that abortion is nothing less than murder unless it's done to save the life of the mother.
    He has done more to promote that than any other president since the 1973 court decision of Roe v Wade.

    We want our country to show the world that we will (and now are) not a pansy to be abused. We see Trump undoing all the
    bad, and even un-constitutional executive orders by Obama and Clinton that all but gave away our sovereignty. Trump will never be abased by other countries into apologizing like Obama did.

    Obama decimated our military availability of ammunitions. Almost as much as Clinton did. Ask any military officer who served during Clinton and they will tell you if any other large country were to invade us, we would have lost. Although Bush re-vitalized our military defense ability, Obama tried his best to dis-arm us.
    Trump immediately upon taking office fixed that and now we are 1000% more secure against attack than the 8 years prior to his election.
    We heave a sigh of relief that Trump won and did that and we don't want that progress to be abated.

    We can trust Trump will do his best to fulfill his campaign promises. That's something no other elected official in our lifetime has done.

    Hope this answers some of your question.
     
  5. Dane

    Dane Account Deleted

    Oh , one more thing.

    Trump is doing his best to keep us from changing from a republic into socialism like Biden openly admits to.
     
  6. Dane

    Dane Account Deleted

    Pussycat, my direct apologies to you. Those last few post by you shows you have done your homework. I really like the observation by a non-USA person that the democrats are a brainwashed group. Even in our Supreme Court, it's only the liberal democrats that lock-step in all their votes. We conservatives have been saying that since Johnson and his Great Giveaway. (Officially the "Great Society")

    Trump's nomination of conservative SC justices is a MAJOR reason we like him. Although he is the worst politician in history when it comes to speaking, he isn't afraid to say or do what he believes is the truth.

    We like him because he has called out the media-bias and their twisting of facts, his "Fake News" terminology.

    Yes we are still mainly a Christian based nation ( quickly becoming less and less so), and Trump wants to stop that.
    Secularism is becoming such a major switch that Evangelicals are trying harder than ever to band together in the knowledge that since the USA has become more secular, it has experienced a great rise in violence and and crime. The "Everyman for himself" attitude.

    I AM NOT saying Secularism promotes violence, it is working just fine in other countries, but in the USA, the Secularists are for the most part the reason for the upswing in crimes and Secularists are mainly democrat in their political position.
    We like Trump because he understands that also. He had said so himself.
     
    LuckyDuck, EggHead, orly6666 and 2 others like this.
  7. Brutus58

    Brutus58 Trusted.Member

    You pretty much have said it it correctly. I disagree with a couple of minor points, but mostl you have it right.
     
  8. Brutus58

    Brutus58 Trusted.Member

    I voted for Ross Perot. If he is still alive maybe he should have been Trumps's VP.
     
  9. Curmudgeon

    Curmudgeon Moderator Staff Member

    Ross Perot ran his campaign like he ran his business. When asked how he would fix something he didn't have an answer. His only plan was to issue an edict and it would be handled. That might work when you are the CEO of a company but doesn't work running a country. If he had even a basic plan, and could vocalize it, he could possibly have become president.
     
    Dane likes this.
  10. kingshadow2

    kingshadow2 Account Deleted


    Good written and clear reason why you and many like him, Thank you :)
     
    Dane likes this.
  11. Dane

    Dane Account Deleted

    Curmudgeon, exactly, but Trump is why a business man was elected into office when Perot wasn't.
    The last business man elected into office was Jimmy Carter. By far the voted most horrible president elected in the 20th century. Problem was is that he was a small-business man.

    Kingdark, Conservative Americans knew that we needed a business man in office and Trump is used to working in the mega bucks arena.
    The liberals just wanted another yes-man, glib talking, politician who would try to fulfill their dream of turning our government into a form of socialism. as Pussycat stated " Democrat voters are brainwashed because, metaphorically, if you try to tell them the truth, they will stick their fingers in their ears and say la la la la la. ", no matter how history shows socialism always ends in the demise of a country.
     
    EggHead likes this.
  12. pussycat

    pussycat Administrator Staff Member

    I didn't say that. And I certainly don't agree with it. :(
     
    Dane likes this.
  13. Dane

    Dane Account Deleted

    Sorry Pussycat! It was a typo.
    Meant to have typed Neophyte, not you!
     
  14. kingshadow2

    kingshadow2 Account Deleted

    Often Rebublicans and even Democrats use the word Sosialist in a negative term. All Scandinavian contries are. And if you do a quick google or wikipedia serarch, you will se we all do kinda great.
    I was toying with the Idea of mabe making thread where you could ask questians about it, if you are curious. Could do it her also, if anyone wants to.
     
  15. pussycat

    pussycat Administrator Staff Member

    You can start a thread to that effect if you wish. It may well lead to some intelligent and informed discussion. It may also lead to being swamped by rants from those right wing members here who seem to believe that anything not to the right of Mussolini is outright communism.
    Unfortunately, the ghost of Joe McCarthy is alive and well in the USA, and well represented on this forum.
    But feel free, it might be quite entertaining. :)
     
    kingshadow2 likes this.
  16. Brutus58

    Brutus58 Trusted.Member

    Out of curiosity, on a scale of extreme left (0) to the extreme right (10), where would you place ( Ilduce ) Mussolini?
     
  17. kingshadow2

    kingshadow2 Account Deleted

    Intresting question. I know you did not ask me. But fascisme have socialist economic ideas and politics, but at the same time controls the population in a manner we think of as far right.

    So on an economic scale they are Centrum oriented, with an oppressive government form. One often think if NSDAP (nazi) Nationalsozialistische Deutsche Arbeiterpartei (national socialist German workers party) , it sounds a bit left dont it.... and it was!
    And Musolini and the Italian facist where not Nazis, but the Nazis where fascist. Mussolini did not like the Germans focus on race and tought it conter productive. And they wher not to enthusiastic about hunting Jews, but they did, to some extend.

    It is in my mind a bit hard to place the facist on a 1 to 10 scale.

     
    Brutus58 and pussycat like this.
  18. pussycat

    pussycat Administrator Staff Member

    To ask that question shows an indication of linear thinking - something I believe the USA suffers from to an extreme degree. Call it polarization if you prefer.
    Take a piece of string and stretch it straight. You have point A at one end and point B at the other. A being left, B being right, as far apart as possible. That's the American perspective all to often.
    Take the same piece of string and lay it down as a circle. A and B now touch. How far apart are they?
    Extreme right, extreme left, call them what you wish, all result in the same thing - totalitarianism. Total state control of everything.
    The arguement of who is right, who is left, it's all nonsense. Don't ask where you fit on that line between A and B, ask where you fit within the circle.
    And if you want to get really sophisticated, start drawing Venn diagrams and drive yourself mental. Let me know how you make out.
     
    Last edited: Oct 25, 2020
    Brutus58 likes this.
  19. pussycat

    pussycat Administrator Staff Member

    You might also consider the fact that all societies are, by definition and action, socialist.
    It's only a matter of to what degree.
     
    Dane likes this.
  20. pussycat

    pussycat Administrator Staff Member

    Kingdark 1, if you looked at an electoral map of the USA by county, you would find that almost all highly urban electoral districts vote Democrat (left), and almost all mostly rural districts vote Republican (right).
    I think that this would hold true in any democracy you might pick. It certainly does up here.
     
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.